Top Camera Review

Do-it-all with good ideas and many issues.

by Pu on September 13, 2011

Top Camera is a do-it-all camera app that can both take photos and record videos and allows sharing and, to a degree, editing. In occasion of its recent launch, Top Camera is currently on sale for 0.99/€0.79/£0.69 in the App Store.

I have tested this photo application thoroughly and, although I recognize there are good ideas in it, I found it has too  many issues to be a truly useful replacement for iPhone’s native camera app.

Main Features

  • Full resolution available;
  • Video recording;
  • Self-timer;
  • Stabilizer;
  • Grid on/off;
  • Virtual horizon on/off;
  • 5x digital zoom;
  • Focus and exposure setting;
  • White balance lock;
  • 4 capturing modes;
  • Crop and rotate;
  • 36 effects;
  • 18 borders;
  • Adjust contrast, brightness, saturation;
  • In-app guide;
  • Send photos via email and share on Facebook, Twitter, Flickr and Dropbox.

Appotography Opinion

To help the user in the task of taking photos and videos, Top Camera comes with individually adjustable focus and exposure, virtual horizon and four capturing modes: Normal, HDR, Burst and Slow Shutter. The Normal mode just takes photos normally; in HDR mode, both auto and manual, the app takes three shots and merges them to create a high dynamic range image; Slow Shutter also merges more shots together to simulate long exposure effects; the Burst mode takes several shots in sequence while pressing the shutter button just once. To improve the performance of each of these modes in difficult conditions, the user can enable a self-timer and a stabilizing feature.

Top Camera iPhoneAll videos and photos taken in-app are automatically stored in the app’s Main Folder. From here they can be viewed, saved, shared, edited (with the exception of videos) and moved to other folders. Users can create and title new folders, importing and moving photos and videos freely among them. The folders feature is one of the best elements in Top Camera, as it permits to keep photos and videos neatly arranged.

Top Camera iPhoneThe Photo Editor offers crop, rotate, adjust brightness, contrast, saturation and improve definition tools. It also includes effects and borders. Effects — 36 in all — range from sepia to lomo-like filters. Borders come in two different styles, basic and vignette. Most adjustments and effects can be applied simply using sliders to regulate their intensity. Reverting to the original image is always possible.

Top Camera comes with many features and options and, in this regard, it would represent and interesting choice in the App Store’s photography section. However, Top Camera’s workflow feels somewhat clunky, the output quality of images is poor and some of the features of this camera lack refinement and thus are not comparable with equivalent features of other apps. Just to make some examples: the HDR feature, since it lacks any tweaking possibility after the shots are taken, is not always fully usable and it tends to produce severe halo artifacts; the edit mode counts several adjustments, effects and borders, but most are quite mediocre and not varied enough — if anything, it looks like they’re just there to give users additional content. Another problem I have encountered using Top Camera is the app sometimes disables the auto-lock feature of the iPhone, which obviously causes it to drain more battery than necessary. Finally, the in-app guide is not very comprehensive and helpful.

Top Camera iPhone

Color Boost (left) and Lomo (right) effects on HDR. Noticeable quality issues at full resolution (bottom).

On average, Top Camera will perhaps satisfy a few of those users looking for a general replacement for the native camera app with some extras that other multi-purpose camera lack. However, for its many issues and especially given the overall quality of images produced with Top Camera, I don’t feel like recommending it.

Overall

Name: Top Camera
Developer: Lucky Clan
Compatibility: iPhone, iPod Touch 4th, iPad 2. iOS 3.1 or later.
Price: £1.99||$2.99||€2.39
Vote: 2/5

Top Camera - photo / video app with HDR, slow shutter, folders and editor - Lucky Clan

ILAR September 14, 2011 at 12:00 am

Precisely! If you haven’t bought it already, wait for the update. If you HAVE to buy a photo app today, buy photogene instead or procamera.

Reply

Grendalin Q September 14, 2011 at 1:03 am

I wanted to buy this, but then I wasn’t very convinced after looking at the decription and at the hdr example they used there. I am happy with King Camera and Camera+, actually, so it was just out of curiosity that I wanted to try Top Camera.

Reply

Miege September 14, 2011 at 2:46 am

What’s wrong with their HDR example?
Anyway, I think Top Camera is a good entry into the App Store due to its and its developers’ versatility. Hopefully in time, it will be better. For the time being, my main camera is Camera 360 (because it has plenty of awesome effects BUT unable to import photos). Camera+ comes second because it has Clarity.

Reply

Grendalin Q September 14, 2011 at 3:12 am

Yes, I like Clarity too.

Reply

Grendalin Q September 14, 2011 at 3:02 am

It looks too fake. I usually am suspicious of apps relying on effects that look so fake. It’s just me, perhaps.

Reply

Miege September 14, 2011 at 4:07 am

Ah, I see. Well, I haven’t tested it thoroughly like PU but that fake but beautiful-looking HDR only happens when I set it to manual. Never happens to auto, though. 😀 HDR is not as fast as Bracket Mode, by the way.

This is off-topic but some fakery can make our life richer. I used to stick to realism when taking pictures but now I’m more laid-back–I shoot and edit according to my heart’s content. 😉

Reply

Grendalin Q September 14, 2011 at 4:16 am

I see your point and I suppose these things depend a lot on taste. I still like HDR when it enhances a good image. Sometimes you have no other way. At first, I thought the fake effect was really cool, but then I got tired of seeing it everywhere and now it kinda bothers me and I try to avoid it because makes me go blergh after five minutes of looking at it. Looks like we’ve been going in opposite directions, lol.

I use Bracket Mode too, although not that often. It’s the best when you have to take more shots.

Reply

ken December 16, 2011 at 8:55 am

anyone using the shutter speed option, good?

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: